A Thousand Acres

Wuthering Bites Book Club Review at a Glance

What We Said

Our review is not in yet

Kay, 9/6/2004    D
I would have never read this book unless it was assigned for summer reading. Compared to the other two books I had to read for my assignment this one was my least favorite. I commend Smiley for her attempts to put a modern spin on King Lear, but I saw no point in the plot summary she chose. It's hard to improve what Shakespeare already wrote. So I kind of knew before even reading it that it certainly wasn't going to be better than Shakespeare. Why did Smiley pick that particular plot? Why did she bother? Those were some of thoughts that I had after reading the back cover. My viewpoints did not change while reading it. The one thing that drove me nuts while reading was the main character Ginny. What a psycho! I can see that perhaps Smiley's point was to show how her father's actions affected her, but her responses to the situation became more and more ridiculous as the book went on. It got to the point where I could no longer connect to Ginny's character because it was not believeable. The only one way I can summarize this book is by saying it would make a great lifetime original movie.
Inspired food accompaniment:   I have no idea what that means? It made me not want to eat pickled sausage. That is for one thing for sure.
Other suggested books/authors:   

Add Your Review

Jane Smiley lives in California with her three children, three dogs, and her sixteen (and counting) horses. Born in Los Angeles, California, Jane moved to the suburbs of St. Louis, Missouri, as an infant, and lived there through grammar school and high school (The John Burroughs School). After getting her BA at Vassar College in 1971, she traveled in Europe for a year, working on an archeological dig and sight-seeing, then returned to Iowa for graduate school at the University of Iowa.
MFA and Ph.D. in hand, she went to work in 1981 at Iowa State University, in Ames, where she taught until 1996. Jane is the author of ten works of fiction, including A Thousand Acres, which won the Pulitzer Prize in 1992, as well as many essays for such magazines as Vogue, The New Yorker, Practical Horseman, Harper's, the New York Times Magazine and the New York Times travel section, Victoria, Mirabella, Allure, The Nation and others. She has written on politics, farming, horse training, child-rearing, literature, impulse buying, getting dressed, Barbie, marriage, and many other topics.

• Age of Grief
• The All-True Travels and Adventures of Lidie Newton
• Barn Blind
• Duplicate Keys
• Greenlanders
• Horse Heaven
• Moo
• Ordinary Love and Good Will
• A Thousand Acres

From the Publisher

When Larry Cook, the aging patriarch of a rich, thriving farm in Iowa, decides to retire, he offers his land to his three daughters. For Ginny and Rose, who live on the farm with their husbands, the gift makes sense—a reward for years of hard work, a challenge to make the farm even more successful. But the youngest, Caroline, a Des Moines lawyer, flatly rejects the idea, and in anger her father cuts her out—setting off an explosive series of events that will leave none of them unchanged. A classic story of contemporary American life, A THOUSAND ACRES strikes at the very heart of what it means to be a father, a daughter, a family. "While she has written beautifully about families in all of her seven preceding books, [this] effort is her best: a family portrait that is also a near-epic investigation into the broad landscape, the thousand dark acres, of the human heart."

Reading Group Guide

These questions and discussion topics are offered to enhance your discussion of this book.

• Discuss how the symbiotic relationship between person and place addressed in Ms. Smiley's choice of epigraph plays itself out in the novel? How does setting shape character? Character shape setting? Which seems to have the upperhand? How is Zebulon County itself a major character in A Thousand Acres?
• What are the strengths and weaknesses of Ginny's narration? Is she able to maintain clarity and candor throughout her chronicling of events? What gets in the way? Is she as forthcoming in discussing herself as she is in discussing others? Why or why not? How would the novel differ if told from the perspective of Rose, Caroline, Jess, or Larry?
• At the outset of the novel, Ginny confesses that retrospection has not revealed too much about the drama that unfolded when her father decided to hand over the farm to Rose and her and leave out Caroline. "I've thought over every moment of that party time and time again, sifting for pointers, signals, ways of knowing how to do things differently from the way they got done, " says Ginny. "There were no clues." To what extent does the story that she then tells undermine this claim? What remains a mystery despite her scrutiny?
• What are the most tragic elements of A Thousand Acres? From what do they arise? Which of these elements are rooted in the exercise of an individual will, and which seem attributable to something beyond the scope of human volition? Where does the novel ultimately come down on the enduring fate-versus-will dilemma?
• What do you see as Ms. Smiley's debt to Shakespeare's King Lear? Where do the two works part ways? What provides A ThousandAcres a certain autonomy despite its borrowed plot and characters?
• Which of the issues explored in A Thousand Acres are unique to rural life in America? Which resonate regardless of geography? What does the novel reveal about variations and consistencies in the so-called American character?
• Passion appears in many guises in A Thousand Acres; discuss them. What seems to lie at the root of each? Which do the most damage? Why do some yield to a desire for authority, acreage, or another, while others resist such temptations? Is there greater freedom in following passion or in checking it? What does the novel teach us about the nature of passion, restraint, and indulgence?
• The interior lives of Caroline as well as Larry remain relatively unexamined compared to those of Rose and Ginny, their spouses, and Jess. What is the dramatic and thematic significance of keeping these characters somewhat shadowy?
• Contemplating her father's momentous decision, Ginny marvels at its apparent rashness. "He decided to change his whole life on Wednesday!" she exclaims."Objectively this is an absurdity." Her remark points to the rich interplay between chance and well-laid plans that appears throughout A Thousand Acres. How does the deliberate and daily work of generations stand up against the vicissitudes of the natural world and the whims of human nature? What kind of solace and safety, if any, do seasonal chores and rituals provide?
• Discuss the myriad ways that motherhood--and fatherhood-- are weighed in the novel. How does Ginny's ineluctable desire to give birth shape her view of her present and past? What meaning does she locate in the many surrogate-maternal roles she plays? In what ways is her mother's long absence a constant presence?
• "Our bond had a peculiar fertility that I was wise enough to appreciate, and also, perhaps, wise enough to appreciate in silence, " Ginny says. "Rose wouldn't have stood for any sentimentality." Reticence seems the norm among these characters, yet expression takes place. What are the wordless languages with which these people communicate to one another? What are the reach and limits of each? What are the perils and possibilities?
• Is there a particular politics or ideology at work in A Thousand Acres? What is it? Does construing the novel in terms of, say, feminism limit or enlarge it? What do you see as the novelist's responsibility vis-a-vis politics? Does this work fall closer to agenda or inquiry?
• "The first novel I ever knew was my family, " writes Ms. Smiley in an afterword to a collection of essays on family by contemporary American writers. "We had every necessary element, from the wealth of incident both domestic and historical, to the large cast of characters. We had geographical sweep and the requisite, for an American novel, adven-ture in the West." Discuss A Thousand Acres as a meditation on family. On what dark corners of its dynamic character does the novel shed light? How are the Cooks both anomalous and representative of American families? What explains their tragic dissolution? What could have prevented it? How does sexual abuse factor into the equation?
• What are the benefits and drawbacks of presenting the novel as one long look back? 15. Ginny is stilled by the disturbing thought that her own "endurance might be a pleasant fiction allowed [her] by others who've really faced facts." Is it? Do you construe her story, i. e., the novel, as flight from a difficult reality or a means of confronting it? Why?
• During a game of Monopoly, Jess describes Harold as someone who is "cannier and smarter than he lets on, " then suggests that real freedom exists in "the slippage between what he looks like and what he is." Discuss how the relationship between appearance and reality defines the arc of the novel's action and the meaning and direction of its characters' lives. What kind of importance does Ms. Smiley assign this relationship?
• In what reads like a muted epiphany, Ginny, after time in her garden, considers the constant weight and absence of her mother's death before realizing that one reaches a point where "relief is good enough." Do you read this remark as an expression of resignation or a spirited acceptance of true trial? Why?
• In a candid conversation with Rose, Ginny voices her inability to understand her father's abuse of them, despite Rose's insistence that the matter is a simple case of "I want, I take, I do." Says Ginny, "I can't believe it's that simple." Rose's response: "If you probe and probe and try to understand, it just holds you back." What does this exchange reveal about the limitations of reason? About the possibility or impossibility of true catharsis? What options exist when the rational is exhausted? Is faith considered? If so, faith in what?
• Ms. Smiley now regrets that her novel, like Shakespeare's Lear, precludes the possibility of forgiveness--of a love not limited to a selfish exchange. Do you share her regret? Why or why not?